When your cabinets look dated but the boxes are still solid, you’re facing one real decision: refinish what you have, or replace everything. Here’s how to choose.
The Short Answer
If your cabinet boxes are solid wood and structurally sound, refinishing almost always makes more sense — you get a dramatic visual change at 30-50% of replacement cost. Replacement only makes sense when boxes are damaged, made of particleboard that’s swelling, or you’re changing the kitchen layout.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Refinishing | Full Replacement | |
|---|---|---|
| Typical cost | $1,500 – $6,500 | $8,000 – $25,000+ |
| Timeline | 2 – 5 days | 3 – 8 weeks |
| Keeps existing layout | Yes | Optional |
| Best for | Solid cabinets, dated finish | Damaged boxes, layout change |
Not sure which your kitchen needs? We’ll assess your cabinets in person, free, and tell you honestly which option makes sense. Get your free estimate or call (904) 820-5573.
Signs Your Cabinets Are Good Candidates for Refinishing
- Boxes are solid wood or plywood (not particleboard)
- Doors and drawers open and close properly, no sagging
- No water damage, swelling, or delamination
- You like the current layout, just not the color or finish
Signs You Should Consider Replacement Instead
- Particleboard boxes are swelling or crumbling
- You want to change the kitchen layout or add cabinets
- Doors are warped or water-damaged beyond repair
- You want different cabinet construction (soft-close, different depth)
What About Refacing?
Refacing sits between the two: it keeps your cabinet boxes but replaces doors and drawer fronts with new ones, typically costing $4,000-$9,500. It’s a good middle option when doors are damaged but boxes are fine and you want a different door style, not just a different color.
Get an Honest Assessment
The only way to know for sure which option fits your kitchen is an in-person look at your actual cabinets. We provide free, no-obligation assessments across Jacksonville.
Request your free cabinet assessment or call us today at (904) 820-5573.
